News

Do Feed Additives Really Work, or Is It Just Marketing?

Do feed additives really work, or is it just marketing? It is one of the questions we hear most often from farmers and feed millers, and usually it comes right after a sales visit or a brochure full of big promises. It is a fair question. Feed is one of the largest costs on any livestock farm, and every extra euro per tonne has to earn its place.

In the first episode of our CEO Insights series, our Managing Director, Dr. Omid Samadijavan, answers it from inside the production chain. Before leading 3A Austria, Omid worked as a production manager for feed millers and for dairy, broiler and layer farms.

Watch the short episode with Omid, then read on for our view in more detail.

Why farmers ask this question

Omid remembers arriving at the office as a production manager and finding his desk covered in catalogues. Most of them said the same thing: use this feed additive, and that will happen. For the farm, each of those promises meant one thing first: an extra cost in production.

That matters, because margins in livestock production are thin. Farmers have little room between what they spend on feed and what they receive for milk, meat or eggs, and they do not set those prices. In that situation, a product that does not address a real problem on the farm is not neutral. It is money taken out of an already tight budget.

This is why we do not think the honest answer is a simple yes or no. As Omid puts it:

"The matter is not our promises. The matter is a solution that works."

When feed additives make sense: start with a clear target

Omid's answer in the episode is yes, with one condition: "feed additives are useful if you use feed additives for clear targets."

A clear target means starting with the farm, not with the product. What is the challenge in this herd or flock? Is it feed efficiency, gut health in a demanding phase, the quality of the raw materials, or a specific stage of production? Once the target is defined, it becomes possible to choose an additive that is designed to support that goal and to check, on the farm, whether it fits the operation.

Without a target, even a well-made product becomes a line on the invoice rather than a tool. For an overview by species, see our explainers on feed additives for cattle and feed additives for poultry.

Dosage, mixing and practical use

Choosing the product is only half of the work. The other half happens in the feed mill and on the farm.

Omid gives a simple example: a dosage of 100 g per tonne of feed. Mixing 100 g evenly into one metric tonne is not easy. If the feed miller or the farmer is not shown how to do it, through premixing, the right order of addition and enough mixing time, the product may not be spread evenly through the feed. The farmer pays for it without getting the value it was chosen for.

This is why we see technical support as part of the product. Clear instructions for dosage, mixing, storage and the rest of the diet should come with every recommendation.

Marketing versus experience on the farm

In Omid's view, there are many products out there, and many sellers who are mainly involved in marketing and have little experience on farms. When a product is sold with the wrong instructions, the farmer sees no results, carries extra costs, and the whole category of feed additives gets a bad image.

Our approach follows three steps. First, we ask the farmer what the problem is. Second, we introduce the solution that fits that problem. Third, we show how to use it in practice.

Cost belongs in the same conversation. Ours is not a luxury industry. A product often passes through several layers, from manufacturer to distributor to local distributor, before it reaches the farm, and each layer adds to the price. When we recommend a feed additive, the costs and benefits for the farmer have to make sense at the end of that chain.

What to ask a feed additive supplier

Before you add a new product, these questions help separate a real solution from a sales pitch:

  • What specific problem on my farm is this product meant to address?
  • Which target do we agree on, and how will we check it on my farm?
  • What is the dosage per tonne, and how should it be mixed in my feed mill or on my farm?
  • Who supports us during the first batches if something does not go as planned?
  • Does the cost fit my margin, and what does the price include along the supply chain?
  • Does the person recommending it have practical experience with animals like mine?

Send us your questions for the next episodes

This first episode is only the start. In the next episodes of CEO Insights, Omid will go into more detail, and we want the questions to come from you. If you have a question about feed additives, animal nutrition or livestock feeding, write to us at office@3a-austria.eu.

To see what we offer, browse our feed additives, or read more about 3A Austria and how we work with partners on three continents.

2026-11-12 15:07